Keyed vs. keyless connections: What’s the difference and why does it matter?

While both keyed and keyless connections serve the same purpose of transmitting torque, they operate in fundamentally different ways.  Understanding the distinctions between the two connection types can help you choose the best option for your systems.

keyless shaft

keyed shaft

keyedShaft

The reliability and efficiency of mechanical connections dictate the smooth operation of machinery and equipment.  Specifically, the method of mechanical component connection, keyed vs. keyless, has a significant impact on performance.

While both keyed and keyless connections serve the same purpose of transmitting torque, they operate in fundamentally different ways.  Understanding the distinctions between the two connection types can help you choose the best option for your systems.

Keyed connections

Keyed connections are the traditional method for securing rotating shafts to power transmission components, such as gears, sprockets, and lever arms. The basic principle behind a keyed connection is the use of a key, a small, metal component that fits into a keyway in both the shaft and the hub of the connected parts. The key locks the two parts together, preventing them from slipping or rotating independently of each other. 

Advantages of keyed connections

  • More tolerance: A keyed connection will allow for more tolerance between the two mating parts, but the mating parts for a keyless connection must be cleaned and machined to precise tolerances.
  • Simplicity and reliability: Keyed connections are relatively simple to design and implement. They have been used for over a century in mechanical systems and are widely trusted for their reliability.
  • Ease of maintenance and repair: If a part fails or wears out, it’s relatively easy to replace the key and continue using the existing shaft and hub. This makes maintenance easier and cost-effective.
  • Cost-effective: The materials used to create keyed connections (such as keys and keyways) are inexpensive, and the manufacturing process is straightforward.
  • Positive stop until failure: A keyed connection will provide positive stop until failure, but a keyless connection could allow slippage between the two mating parts if not assembled correctly or the design torque is exceeded.
  • Visual check: A keyed connection provides a visual that the mating parts are locked into place.

Disadvantages of keyed connections

  • Precision issues: The keyway introduces an element of misalignment, as the fit between the key and the keyway must be precise. Even slight deviations can lead to operational issues.
  • Stress concentration: The keyway creates a groove in the shaft or hub, which can lead to stress concentration and potential material failure over time. This is especially problematic in high-torque applications.
  • Wear and tear: Over time, the key and keyway can experience wear, which could cause slippage and misalignment, reducing the efficiency of the power transmission system.

Keyless Connections

In contrast to keyed connections, keyless connections use friction or other methods to secure the shaft and hub together without the need for a key. Instead of relying on a key to transmit torque, keyless connections use an interference fit, where the components are tightly pressed together using mechanical force, to handle applications with inconsistent power. This can be achieved through various mechanisms, such as split hubs, clamping rings, or bushing-type connections.

Advantages of keyless connections

  • Higher torque capacity: Without the stress concentration caused by a keyway, keyless connections can transmit more torque, making them ideal for high-performance applications.
  • No wear from keyways: Since there is no key or keyway, there is no wear from those components. This can lead to longer operational life and better efficiency.
  • Improved precision: Keyless connections can provide a more accurate and secure fit, resulting in less vibration and better alignment of the connected components.
  • Reduced risk of failure: Without the potential for keyway-related wear, keyless connections tend to be more reliable over time, especially in heavy-duty or high-speed applications.
  • Timing adjustment possible: On occasion, two drives must be timed to each other.  When using a keyed input, the timing is only adjustable to one revolution of input divided by the ratio.  With a keyless connection the adjustment is infinite.
  • Ease of removal: With keyless connections, fretting corrosion is very unlikely to occur.  Removal of the gearbox from the motor will be relatively easy.

Disadvantages of Keyless Connections

  • Installation challenges: Proper installation of keyless connections requires more precision and may need special tools to ensure the correct interference fit.  However, if a motor is mounted to a reducer or a reducer mounted to a keyless drive shaft, the shaft position is not a concern and the motor or reducer shaft can slide on in any position, which makes the installation easier.
  • Cost and complexity: Keyless connections are generally more expensive and complex to design and manufacture than keyed connections. The added cost may not always justify the benefits for lower-torque applications.
  • Difficult maintenance: If a keyless connection fails, the repair process can be more complicated. Unlike keyed connections, which can simply have the key replaced, keyless systems may require the replacement of the entire clamping mechanism.

When to use keyed vs. keyless connections

The choice between keyed and keyless connections depends on several factors, including the specific needs of the application:

  • Keyed connections are often the best choice for standard or lower-torque applications where cost-effectiveness and ease of maintenance are important. They are suitable for many industrial machines, where the torque requirements are moderate, and where ease of repair and replacement is a priority.
  • Keyless connections are ideal for high-torque, high-performance applications, such as in motors, turbines, or aerospace components, where precision, reliability, and longevity are critical. They provide superior torque transfer, reduced wear, and improved alignment, making them worth the extra cost in demanding environments.

Both keyed and keyless connections offer advantages when applied in the power transmission world. Understanding the trade-offs in terms of cost, performance, and long-term reliability is key to making the right choice for your system. While keyed connections remain a trusted, cost-effective solution for many applications, keyless connections offer superior performance and durability in demanding, high-torque environments.

By carefully considering the specific needs of your application, you can make an informed decision about whether keyed versus keyless connection is the right choice for your application.

Download our eBook about gearbox selection to learn more or contact us at (888) 786-2371 or email sales@stober.com for help determining what gearbox is most appropriate for your application.

Our Three Pillars – Quality, Delivery, Service

0425 Stober3274 e1675957132768

Mechatronics suppliers are plentiful, but they aren’t all made equal. STOBER is proud to be the gold standard, with top-notch industry knowledge and industry-leading products.

IMG 1810 e1690465049118

Are you frustrated by the current lead times you’re being quoted? At STOBER, we’re proud to build and ship in one day from our facility in Maysville, Kentucky.

serviceDept

STOBER’s service department offers several levels of expert analysis to inspect products after they have been installed in the field. Our team is committed to having you back up and running as quickly as possible.